on 6/28/2009
Man oh man. Each falls short of perfection in the same way.
on 10/5/2009
I can see some imperfections in 'Nightmare Before Christmas' but what is flawed in 'Edward Scissorhands'? (other than the ending, of course)
on 3/1/2010
*beep* my two favorite 'Burton' films, I guess this time I'll go with TNBC.
on 7/1/2010
Nightmare Befor Christmas. I love Jack Skellington but never really got into Edward Scissorhands.
on 1/1/2013
Close call, but "Scissorhands" is the greater masterpiece of the two.
on 2/10/2013
Edward Scissorhands is one of Tim Burton best. The Nightmare Before Christmas was not very good in my opinion.
on 2/10/2013
Two amazing Tim Burton films but my favourite has got to be Edward Scissorhands. Love Johnny Depp :D
on 2/10/2013
Edward Scissorhands...and might I say...quite easily.
on 2/10/2013
Edward Scissorhands
on 4/20/2013
Scissorhands
on 4/20/2013
The Nightmare Before Christmas. But only just, and on account of my love for stop motion.
on 6/3/2014
one of the best ''Animated'' film ever in Nightmare but I love the quirky and original Scissorhands so dark and yet beautiful.
on 6/4/2014
Edward Scissorhands
on 10/25/2015
'Edward Scissorhands' races up to the top of my film ranking list and meets with my number 1 film 'The Nightmare Before Christmas'. A painfully hard choice. I constantly watched these movies when I was a baby. If I were 2 years old now I would definitely pick TNBC. I was scared of ES but now I absolutely adore it. Music equally fantastic, visuals equally fantastic. If I pick which one has the best characters though... then it will have to be ES.
on 10/25/2015
Edward scissorhands is one of my favourites
on 8/13/2021
Both trash and leave you depressed and disturbed, but I actually finished Scissorhands so it wins
